23 February 2011


As I was sitting at the computer in my air-conditioned classroom at 7.30am this very morning a smiling student knocked on my door and came in solely to give me a sweet. Later, I announced to my Year 9 class (fourteen year olds) that I wanted their exercise books in, their copies of "Rice Without Rain" by the Thai writer Mingfong Ho and that they were to put their chairs under their desks tidily. Moments later, after they had gone, I looked across the room and saw that all chairs had indeed been put under the desks and on the front tables there were two neat piles - exercise books and novels. I didn't have to try. It just happened.

In contrast, I remember two horrid fifteen year old boys I taught in my last full year of secondary school teaching in north Sheffield. Martin and Louis were always late for lessons. Every time I challenged them they became surly and obstreperous, snarling back: "Nobody else bothers if we're late" or "What ye going on abaht?" or "We're only five minutes late - ger over it!". Louis never had a pen to write with. Getting work out of him was like getting blood out of a stone and his arrogant chum Martin was not much better. Their body language spoke volumes - rocking on their chairs, failing to sustain polite eye contact. I wrote to their parents, kept them back for detentions, reported them to the Senior Learning Mentor - all to no avail. Both of these boys had plenty of latent ability but they had chosen not to nourish it.

I'm not saying that all secondary school children in working class urban areas of Britain are like Louis and Martin. Many youngsters remain polite, focussed, willing and grateful of the help you give them. But there is a boorish and influential core of reluctant, argumentative and downright lazy kids who seem to do their best to turn education into drudgery. It should be happy, enlightening, pleasant. Being in Thailand reminds me that it really can be that way - adults and young people working together in an atmosphere of mutual respect, feeling a sense of joy about the very human business of learning.


  1. well said that man.....
    having said this...I so so miss that sheffield twang!

    keep cool mr pud

  2. It used to be like that here too half a century ago. Where did we go wrong?

  3. Remember how Clinton had that sign that said, "It's the economy, stupid!" over his desk? Well, maybe you don't. But anyway, I think each teacher should have a sign over their's that says, "It's the parents, stupid!".

    Respect, respect, respect. If the children are not taught to respect their parents, their neighbors, their law enforcement officers, etc., what hope is there that they would respect their teachers? Who do they learn to respect? Rock stars and football players!

    It's the stupid parents!

  4. We are often careless with the things we take for granted in the west where education for some has become a right to be abused, rather than a privilege to be cherished,

  5. JOHN GRAY Keep cool? It's a sweltering 35 degrees outside my door old chum. I feel like a character in "Some Like it Hot".
    JENNY I think Madam Thyme and Mr Parrots have provided key pointers to the solution.
    M.THYME Neither of my children ever had any trouble at school - no detentions, no letters home. Teachers always said what nice people they were and to me that means a great deal. Shirley and I always tried to be the best parents we could be.
    SHOOTING PARROTS Genuinely, your observation belongs in a book of modern quotations. You said it so well.

  6. I found that mutual respect sometimes when teaching teenagers: I find it all the time teaching medical students. I love it. I do think it has to be earned - - but there are some teenagers for whom, it seems, teachers can work their socks off and they still look at you with contempt. Sighhh.


Mr Pudding welcomes all genuine comments - even those with which he disagrees. However, puerile or abusive comments from anonymous contributors will continue to be given the short shrift they deserve. Any spam comments that get through Google/Blogger defences will also be quickly deleted.

Most Visits