Whenever I hear this kind of thing it makes me bristle because it is patently not true and in my view it is both unkind and illogical. Let me dig into this.
Every society is like a jigsaw. You need all the parts. There must be road workers, nurses, hotel cleaners, car mechanics, teachers, police officers, lorry drivers, farmers, factory workers and baggage handlers. If everybody was a pop star or a dancer on the West End stage or a professional footballer or a published author then society would simply fall apart. It could not properly function.
Which young people ever dreamt of becoming a hospital cleaner or a digger of holes or a roofer? That is not to demean those roles because I said before, we need them. People who get up in the morning and don their work clothes, day after day. They are the real heroes, the true stars for they are definitely not being who they "want to be". They are living in the real world.
Usually, the people who spout the "you can do anything if you strive hard enough" myth are folk who have "made it" in entertainment or sport. And yet when you think about those two fields, they do not belong to the Christmas cake of life, they are "extra" like the icing on the top - not integral to the core businesses of society. And what is more, the percentage of people who earn their living through professional sport, entertainment or writing is very small indeed - measurable in tiny fractions.
Don't get me wrong. I think it is important for people to have aspirations but in my opinion those dreams should be rooted in reality - the art of the possible. Being encouraged to go for unreachable dreams is arguably downright cruel.
Of course it is easier to pursue "anything you want" dreams when you enjoy good physical and mental health, when you have nice parents who live in nice houses, take nice holidays and have money in the bank, when you receive a decent education, when your immediate peers are also well-advantaged. It is not so easy to pursue if you are born into poverty, if you have a significant disability, if you have no wholesome role models close by. Then the mountain you have to climb is so much taller, the path more treacherous.
Superficial instagram social media messaging suggests a world where it is easy to "make it". All you have to do is dream hard enough and strive for the top. Then the fruits of success will follow. But of course life is not like that.
Besides, if you are one of the tiny number of people who "make it", will you be happy? Will you be contented with your lot?
I doubt that the "you can be anything you want to be" myth brigade are ever really thinking about simply being warm and safe, loving and being loved, enjoying good health, putting food on the table, doing kind things and being a loyal friend.
Their trite message is pure hogwash. Well, for what it's worth, that's what I think.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Mr Pudding welcomes all genuine comments - even those with which he disagrees. However, puerile or abusive comments from anonymous contributors will continue to be given the short shrift they deserve. Any spam comments that get through Google/Blogger defences will also be quickly deleted.